ERISA Litigation

Complying with the myriad of complex employee benefits rules can be mystifying. The attorneys in Ulmer & Berne’s employee benefits practice have extensive experience in virtually all aspects of employee benefits and ERISA. We pride ourselves in being able to communicate complex employee benefits issues to our clients in an understandable and usable fashion. Areas of expertise include the following:

  • Employee benefit plan design and compliance, including pension and welfare plans;
  • Executive compensation and nonqualified plans;
  • Employee benefits issues in business transactions; and
  • Employee benefits litigation.

Employee Benefit Plan Design and Compliance
Pension Plans. We have significant experience designing, drafting and working with all types of employee pension benefit plans, including profit sharing, 401(k), money purchase, defined benefit pension (including cash balance) and ESOPs. We regularly advise clients with respect to operational and administrative issues relating to such matters as non-discrimination testing, plan mergers, spin-offs and terminations, plan distributions, participant loans, contribution allocations and limitations, deduction issues, forfeiture allocations, amendment procedures, investment direction, investment policies, qualified domestic relations orders, plan investments in employer securities and employer real property, prohibited transactions, and fiduciary responsibility issues.

In addition, members of our employee benefits practice are frequently involved in the analysis of controlled group and affiliated service group status. We represent clients in audit controversies with the Internal Revenue Service and Department of Labor and assist clients in seeking private letter rulings, advisory opinions and prohibited transaction exemptions.

Welfare Plans. We have significant experience in designing, drafting and consulting with respect to all types of welfare benefit programs, including medical benefit plans, retiree medical plans, medical reimbursement plans, disability plans, group term life insurance, dependent care, cafeteria plans, voluntary employee beneficiary associations (VEBAs) and educational assistance programs.  We assist employers and insurers with claims issues and compliance with the complex ERISA claims procedures, privacy rules under HIPAA, and continuation health coverage under COBRA.  

Executive Compensation and Nonqualified Plans
We have extensive experience representing business and key executives in connection with the formulation, negotiation, drafting and interpretation of employment agreements, severance agreements and a wide variety of executive compensation benefit plans, including stock option plans, phantom stock plans, stock appreciation rights plans, split-dollar life insurance agreements, excess benefit plans, top hat deferred compensation agreements and rabbi trusts, including compliance with the new Code Section 409A. 

Employee Benefits Issues in Business Transactions
We assist clients with benefits issues arising in connection with purchases and sales of businesses. Such assistance includes drafting, reviewing and negotiating appropriate benefits representations and warranties and indemnifications in purchase and sales agreements. In connection with business acquisitions, we analyze the seller’s employee benefit plans, prepare tables comparing the seller’s programs with the buyer’s programs and outlining problem areas, and assist the client with integration of employee benefit programs. We also analyze issues involved in buying and selling businesses from or to employee benefit plans.

Employee Benefits Litigation
We handle numerous employee benefit litigation matters. These matters are approached as a team, with a member of the employee benefits practice and a member of the Firm’s business litigation practice. We represent businesses of all sizes, fiduciaries, insurers and financial providers in connection with ERISA disputes on a regular basis. We have handled routine claims for benefits, breach of fiduciary duty claims, wrongful termination of employment for purposes of denying employee benefits (510 claims), defense of employers against multiemployer benefit plan claims, representation of plan administrators in connection with qualified domestic relations order disputes and representation of clients in connection with litigation brought by governmental entities. We also have extensive experience and expertise in representing employers in connection with withdrawal liability issues under multiemployer pension plans.

Attorneys
Alexander M. Andrews
Yelena Boxer
Jeffrey S. Dunlap
William D. Edwards
Patrick J. Egan
LaDavia S. Hatcher
Ronald H. Isroff
Rebecca B. Jacobs
Ronald L. Kahn
Patricia A. Shlonsky
Stephanie E. Trudeau
Michael N. Ungar

 

Clients

 

Representative Experience

Defended international financial services company in a claim for medical benefits.  The case was settled.

Defended wholesale distributor in connection with a class action filed with respect to 401(k) benefits. This case was settled.

Defended national employee benefits administrator in connection with a breach of fiduciary duty claim involving beneficiary of life insurance proceeds. Successfully negotiated favorable resolution.

Represented third party administrator in connection with claims for distribution and breach of fiduciary duty related to failure to diversify plan assets and succeeded in having numerous claims dismissed, pending.

Defended international telecommunications company in connection with pension plan participant’s claim for benefits in excess of actual entitlement. Motion to dismiss granted; case settled on favorable terms while appeal pending.

Obtained summary judgment for international telecommunications company in the defense of claims that plaintiff was improperly denied disability benefits and that plaintiff’s employment was terminated for the purpose of interfering with plaintiff’s rights under ERISA.  Case settled on favorable terms after plaintiff appealed to the Sixth Circuit.

Represented international telecommunications company against a claim that its failure to credit service under the Pension Plan for maternity leave taken prior to the enactment of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act violated Title VII, the Equal Pay Act, Ohio’s sex discrimination laws and ERISA.

Obtained summary judgment for financial holding company in connection with its exercise of its rights of reimbursement and subrogation under its self-insured medical plan. Also defended  counterclaim against this company for breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA.

Represented a banking and trust company in a breach of fiduciary duty claim arising out of alleged failure to timely invest plan assets.

Defended national paint manufacturer in connection with a series of multi-employer pension plan withdrawal liability disputes.  The case proceeded through arbitration, all the way to the United States Supreme Court and was ultimately settled.

Defended financial services company in a dispute over employee’s entitlement to death benefit related to dependent life insurance, and claims of breach of fiduciary duty.  Obtained summary judgment at trial court level; affirmed on appeal.

Obtained summary judgment on behalf of a client accused of breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA for failing to provide spousal death benefit coverage to employee.  Summary judgment affirmed on appeal by the Tenth District Court of Appeals.

Defended national banking institution, accused of breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA for failing to timely invest participants’ contributions to the pension and profit-sharing plan of a major insurance carrier.

 

Related Practice Areas

Business
Executive & Incentive Compensation
Mergers & Acquisitions

Tax
Employee Benefits/ERISA

 

Case Studies

 

Publications

 

News