Robert J. Karl
Partner

Chair, Environmental Law Group
Environmental (Real Estate)
Environmental (Government Regulation)
Real Estate
Construction Litigation
Acquisition & Development

Columbus Office
p 614.229.0010
f  614.229.0011 p 513.698.5130
f  513.698.5001
bkarl@ulmer.com
At a Glance

Bob chairs the Environmental Law Group and also focuses on real estate, business law and business litigation. He gained valuable experience as Assistant Ohio Attorney General, Environmental Enforcement Section, where he managed and supervised more than 250 water and multi-media civil enforcement actions in various courts, and administrative actions filed before the Environmental Review Appeals Commission. He also represented the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency in diverse actions in various courts.

Practices/Industries
Litigation
Complex Business
Construction Litigation

Government Regulation
Environmental

Real Estate
Acquisition & Development
Environmental

Areas of Concentration
  • Environmental Law & Complex Litigation
  • Environmental Due Diligence
  • Real Estate
  • Business Law
  • Business Litigation
Education
Wright State University (B.A, 1982)

Vermont Law School (J.D., 1989)
Representative Experience
  • Represents business entities, developers, farmers and municipal clients in all phases of environmental compliance, permitting and litigation. Types of cases include CERCLA and NRDA claims, water enforcement and permitting cases, wetland certifications and underground storage tank issues.
  • Counsel to entities subject to state and federal enforcement actions arising under the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act.
  • Counsel to developers in real estate transactions to aid in all aspects of environmental due diligence and other environmental concerns and permitting issues.
  • Has managed and supervised over 250 water and multi-media civil enforcement actions in various courts and administrative actions filed before the Environmental Review Appeals Commission.
  • Has successfully briefed and argued ten appellate cases.
  • Former Assistant Ohio Attorney General, Environmental Enforcement Section
  • More than four years ago, represented the Ohio Department of Natural Resources; defending the Ohio DNR before administrative tribunal, Court of Appeals, and Ohio Supreme Court; prosecution of civil injunctions before Courts of Common Pleas; and representing the Ohio DNR before the U.S. Bankruptcy and Federal Courts.
  • More than four years ago, represented the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency; defending the Ohio EPA before administrative tribunals, Court of Appeals, and Ohio Supreme Court; serving as lead trial attorney in the prosecution of criminal actions and civil injunctions before Courts of Common Pleas and U.S. District Courts; and representation of Ohio EPA before U.S. Bankruptcy Courts in the States of Delaware, Ohio, Pennsylvania and New York.
Honors & Distinctions
Named an "Ohio Super Lawyer" in a survey of Ohio lawyers by Law & Politics and Cincinnati magazines (January 2006-2008)

Named to Best Lawyers in America, Environmental Law, Woodward/White (2007 and 2008)

Ohio Attorney General Professionalism Award (Recipient, 2001)

Conference of Government Mining Attorneys (Chairperson 1992-1993)

Ohio Representative, National Association of Attorneys General (Environmental Issues, CAFO working group, 1998-2002)
Publications & Presentations

Publications
Panelist and Speaker, annual Conference Of Government Mining Attorneys, various panel discussions and presentations on legal issues relating to coal mining (1991, 1992, and 1993)

Frequent Speaker, Ohio State Bar Association and Columbus Bar Association, Environmental Committee Seminars and Luncheons

Presentations
“Earth, Wind & Fire – Energy Sources and Uses,” CREW Cleveland (May 2008)

“Taking Action to Address Global Climate Change:  A Case Law and Legislation Update,” Columbus Bar Association (December 2007)

"CERCLA's AAI Rule Requirements & Revisions to the ASTM Standard," Ohio State Bar Association (April 2006)

"Winning Contract Provisions II, Managing Environmental & Real Estate Risk," CLE, Inc. (April 2006)

"Environmental Practice Comes of Age, How to Market Environmental Opportunities," Lawyers Associated Worldwide (October 2005)

"Real Property Development from Acquisition to Zoning," CLE, Inc. (December 2002; December 2003)

"General Considerations in Representing a Mold Affected Client: Mold Litigation and Risk Management" (October 2003)

"Environmental Matters in the Real Estate Transaction," CLE, Inc. (October 2002)

"Basics of Environmental Enforcement," Ohio State Bar Association (May 2002)

"Basics of Water Pollution Control," Ohio State Bar Association (May 2002)

"The Ohio Experience: CAFO's Regulation in Ohio," National Association of Attorneys General (July 1999)

"Effective Communication of Scientific & Technical Information," Columbus Bar Association (February 1999)

"Environmental Law: Bed Rock Series," Columbus Bar Association (May 1999)

"Environmental Practice Before Agencies and the Courts - A General Primer," Ohio State Bar Association (September 1997)

Professional Affiliations
Lawyer's Associated Worldwide
American Bar Association
Ohio State Bar Association
Columbus Bar Association (Past Co-Chair, Environmental Section)
National Brownfield Association
Admissions
State of Ohio
U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio
U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit